Have any of our dog owners tried those soy fiber dog collars/ harnesses(on their dog)

My pup is growing so fast and at 5 mo old we’re working on replacing her collar for the 3rd time. I like the idea of the soy(natural fiber) but how do they hold up, like say for dogs that like jumping in water? The common nylon web collars are practically bullet proof but they are made of, well, plastic really.