Social Question

joscketSeper's avatar

Why is it that many working class hispanic people in the US are embarrased to listen to American/foreign music?

Asked by joscketSeper (323points) April 12th, 2010

I’m hispanic so I see this alot. My relatives, friends, laborers I see, and meet and that i have worked with. Even though they live in America and could easily tune in to any station in the radio, they always put on the Spanish language radio stations.

Do they hate English, or whatever other foreign music OR is it that they are embarrased to show that they like music other than their country’s music?

Here are some examples of where i see this happening
=Guy that cleans carpets and car carpets.
=Car mechanic
=gardeners
=Hispanics having parties at parks or in their homes

Again, I’m not talking about Hispanic americans who were born in USA and were raised here, or hispanics who immigrated but are taking english classes or what have you and do take an interest in American culture.
I’m talking about working class latinos that have lived here for years but still identify mostly to their own culture and speak mostly Spanish.

I know it may be different in other places (I’m in CAlif) and that it may vary from person to person but for the most part, and from my experience with many laborers and working hispanics(mainly mexican hispanics) that’s what I have noticed.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

CyanoticWasp's avatar

People like what they know, what they already like. This has nothing to do with shame or embarrassment; they like what they grew up with. Rock on.

augustlan's avatar

Probably for the same reason that adults tend to listen to the music from their high school years. It’s what they’re comfortable with.

nimarka1's avatar

Nostalgia. I was born in the US but my family is mexican and i love music in spanish. i feel more comfortable def. I feel more at home. They probably listen to it because they feel closer to home.

Grisaille's avatar

If you moved to Japan and didn’t speak much Japanese, would you immediately begin listening to Japanese pop and rock?

mammal's avatar

American music is introspective and depressing, aggressive, or cheesy.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

I didn’t know this was the case – sometimes, in immigrant communities, people both want to assimilate and to reject the culture that they are assimilating to.

JeanPaulSartre's avatar

I think people stick with what they’re used to for the most part – as @CyanoticWasp said. I imagine I’d listen to the same music, more or less, no matter where I lived. I really don’t care for some music from around the world because I’m not used to it – Music is very much an acquired taste – you can try this, for example – try listening to a song of a style you really don’t like, and listen to it 3 times a day for a week… you’ll start to like it, at least a little, and gain more appreciation for the once disliked genre.

mammal's avatar

@JeanPaulSartre i do feel that music has a capacity to affect you differently in different places, i warm to music i hear abroad over a period of time, that i probably wouldn’t engage with back home.

Ludy's avatar

This is my opinion ONLY! Everybody I know that is mexican is closed minded, they are in america, but they manage to create their little Mexico, like a neighborhood where everybody speaks spanish, all the stores are mexican and all the music you hear is hispanic, I really try to enjoy america and try everything it offers, of course i miss my country and recently when I bought this computer the first thing i did was to download my favorite music in spanish that i didn’t listen to for like 6 years but, I’ve learned english, I listen to american radio stations and my life is smoother than the people (hispanic) i feel at home and I’m not afraid to get out there, just saying… ;)

JeanPaulSartre's avatar

@Ludy Every culture tends to do that initially after immigration – living in Brooklyn I can tell you where just about any country’s ex-patriots live… It’s perfectly understandable to want to create a home where you live, and make it as comfortable as possible, especially when your culture is marginalized elsewhere. It took a long time even back when the Irish first came to America, for example for them to be accepted and normalized by America as a whole.

Ludy's avatar

I understand that, I went trough that phase, the hispanic comunity here is not developing and/or using all their potential because the don’t want to get out of their bubble, not even for the rest of their families that have grown up or been born here, how can they support them, and understand them if they don’t share the same backgrounds and traditions, Like my family, they been here for more than 10 years and they have not achieve absolutly nothing. Why do they want to come here ‘The land of opportunity’ if they’re missing on’em?

JeanPaulSartre's avatar

@Ludy Yeah, it’s really hard, especially for older immigrants to assimilate or be assimilated, it’s usually their kids or grandkids that do it. With a few exceptions

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther