Send to a Friend

JLeslie's avatar

Can you help with some math, more specifically calculating statistics?

Asked by JLeslie (65450points) February 5th, 2021

Several days ago I was postulating that the efficacy of the Moderna vaccine might be inaccurate if it was tested in places with low infection rates. I know one place it was tested was where I live, and while the trial was happening there was a very low amount of cases here, so not very much chance to catch it. The person I was talking to said it wouldn’t matter since they used a placebo also, but I think it would. I am checking with the collective to see if I am thinking about this correctly.

It turns out that J&J was tested here also, but I think it was more recently and also J&J was tested in Latin America and South Africa where cases were high.

Yesterday I was watching TV and Gupta or Fauci (I cannot remember which) said similar to what I am saying that, J&J might have a lower efficacy rate, because they were tested in places with high infections.

So my question is, am I correct that if the infection rate in the community is very low, the efficacy rate of the vaccine might be overestimated?

Using Fluther

or

Using Email

Separate multiple emails with commas.
We’ll only use these emails for this message.