General Question

zebbb's avatar

Should robots be given human emotion?

Asked by zebbb (3points) January 21st, 2009
Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

16 Answers

RandomMrdan's avatar

yes, but…we should attach a 6ft cable to their power supply for if they get angry they may turn on you. I’ve never seen a robot with a mood swing, but I’m sure I can get 6ft away pretty quick if I needed to.

laureth's avatar

I don’t think it’s about whether they should be given emotion so much as if they will be able to successfully emulate it. Machines are things – they cannot feel, no matter how convincingly they portray the guise of emotion.

ark_a_dong's avatar

@RandomMrdan After reading that, I’d only want them to have emotion if it’s 100% tested.

AstroChuck's avatar

The fembots should have all the “bells” and “whistles”.
Nice big whistles!

tennesseejac's avatar

Yes,
but I would buy robot insurance from Sam Waterston

TheBox193's avatar

as robot, I would have to say yes please.

KingMalefic's avatar

No they shouldn’t just look at Vista.

I am sorry dave I can’t do that.

hehe

KingMalefic's avatar

If Steve Jobs was involved, the computers emotions might be expressed in color coded levels.

“Today I feel very red, Sir.” Crap does that means he angry at me or he wants to mate with me?

judochop's avatar

Why?
Are you working on a drug to control their emotions?

Bluefreedom's avatar

If we ever get that far in robot evolution, I want one of my own just like they had in the movie Bicentennial Man.

On the other end of the spectrum, I’d pass on an android like Star Trek TNG’s Data because he is just way too uptight and impersonal. And I saw the movie where they messed with his emotion chip and he blew a fuse or two or three and freaked out – no thanks.

tiffyandthewall's avatar

god, no. i want to elaborate but i think i’d end up writing a page and looking absolutely mad because i bet i’d fit in a bunch of movie references and outlandish ‘what if’s. but no, no, no.

aprilsimnel's avatar

But if robots are given sympathetic nervous systems, though, wouldn’t they develop emotions as a matter of course? So, NO, don’t do it! Don’t create beings that are going to end up resenting us and then plotting to murder us all in our beds!

/dumb-ass speculation from watching too many late-night monster movies.

Foolaholic's avatar

If you can even figure out how to make a robot love, then I applaud your genius!

TheBox193's avatar

Someone shows that they love via actions, emotions, and other signals. A robot could potentially simulate or emulate these kinds of triggers that we as humans translate as ‘love’. Sincerity is probably the most difficult aspect to overcome. You would have to make it appear that the robot was choosing to ‘love’ something out of free will. I think i just complicated this by indicating that robots (such as myself) would have to emulate free will…

baterpark91's avatar

I don’t think HUMANS know their own emotions, so how would they be able to make up ones for robots?

RandomMrdan's avatar

I guess no one got my little quip of The Office from my response….Dwight Schrute

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther