General Question

nomtastic's avatar

what does solidarity mean?

Asked by nomtastic (974points) November 26th, 2006
i'm writing a paper on solidarity, and how it plays out in response to crisis. is it a sentiment? am i really standing in solidarity with people who "i feel for" or is that something else? does solidarity require action?
Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

5 Answers

Falimar's avatar
To be effective, solidarity requires action. Otherwise it is sympathy.
evander's avatar
Solidarity most certainly requires action. As Falimar says it would only be sympathy otherwise. Solidarity requires one to take on personal sacrifice, whether it be time organizing, financial support for social movements or the people in question, educating others about the situation others face, lobbying the government in support of just change, etc, etc. Plenty of people feel sorry for the dispossed and disenfranchised of the world, but continue their lives as they always have. They in no way can be described as in solidarity with these folks.
sarahclif's avatar
solidarity requires action. it's not feeling for others, it's doing with them.
bostonite's avatar

The definition I’ve always used comes from a liberation theologian named Ada Maria Isasi Diaz. (though my own politics aren’t Catholic, I think it fair to say that anarchism, and the left generally in the US has recieved some vital inspiration from Latin American libration theology). She has an essay on replacing the idea of charity with solidarity. In it, she argues that solidarity means standing next to those you are trying to be in solidarity with. This departs from, and can require a bit more commitment, more traditional meanings. It means you can’t just say “I am in solidarity with X”. To be in solidarity with an individual or group, the system of social relations must have an increasingly difficult time differentiating between you and the group or individual. It means substantively taking on the burden of the group you are in solidarity with. The implications are complicated, but one key step is not emphasizing difference.

And example: a button that says “straight but not narrow” is intended as a statement of solidarity with queer communities, but a more substantive statement might be a pink triangle worn by a heterosexual individual. It basically says, I’m standing next to you; I’m making those made invisible more visible; and I’m willing to be in the same danger you are in, so that we can all stand together stronger.

As evandar says above, action is important. For example, monetary support for a group or cause is substantive, and fits my definition of solidarity, as the system of relations sees you as similar to the group in question if you are financially connected or supportive.

Espiritus_Corvus's avatar

Unity. Unity into one solid bloc.

Answer this question




to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther