General Question

bezdomnaya's avatar

How much 'fan mail' do you think Alanis Morissette gets kindly informing her that 'no, it isn't actually ironic'?

Asked by bezdomnaya (1435points) March 26th, 2009

Isn’t it ironic? Don’cha think? A little too ironic. And yeah I really do think… Well, apparently, you don’t.

Lurve for people who can make some of the things in the song actually ironic. E.g. Rain on your wedding day is ironic is you’re getting married in the Sahara Desert or if you’re marrying a meteorologist who predicts no rain on that day.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

Sueanne_Tremendous's avatar

The guy in the airplane let his flight insurance lapse that day.

casheroo's avatar

i think the airplane one is ironic.

i had to look up the song

“It’s a black fly in your Chardonnay” Not ironic, unless you spent a lot on the wine..

SpatzieLover's avatar

@casheroo or it’s winter in Wisconsin where’d that damned fly come from?!

Horus515's avatar

What about the line about a death row pardon two minutes too late? THATS TOTALLY IRONIC!! I mean its not as ironic as a black fly in my Chardonay but c’mon, what could be more ironic than THAT?!

sarcasm

bezdomnaya's avatar

The airplane one is indeed the closest to being actually ironic. I still think it falls short of the mark because nothing about the airplane made it impervious to crashing.

This sums up the situations nicely… and is quite comical.

tinyfaery's avatar

According to Dictionary.com her meaning is correct as well. (2nd defintion)

bezdomnaya's avatar

@tinyfaery Her definition of irony is actually just ‘things that suck’ or ‘very poor timing’. But not everyone has to agree with me on this, of course.

The song is actually ‘meta-ironic’: it’s a song about irony that does not contain any/much irony. And meta-irony is very hip. She should be the hipsters’ God.

ubersiren's avatar

She’s gotten such a load of crap for this that I don’t think she deserves. I think any of them can be considered ironic if you look at it in a certain way. Ex: A black fly in chardonnay could be ironic because the fly is black and the wine is white. A death row pardon 2 minutes too late is ironic because a pardon has essentially been given to a dead man.

madcapper's avatar

“It’s a traffic jam when you’re already late ”
This line is not ironic, it is something that happens everyday…

EmpressPixie's avatar

English is a living language. I think you are all being very prescriptive in your lexicographical pursuits. As long as you can understand what she means, and she gives so many examples it is hard not to, I think she deserves a break.

Go descriptive dictionaries, go! Fly and be descriptive!

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther