General Question

FiRE_MaN's avatar

Which would be more likely to break when dropped?

Asked by FiRE_MaN (684points) February 4th, 2010

My friends and i in art class were arguing about which would break more easily, a lap top or Apples new iPad. I am guessing that the ipad is going to have a glass screen like the iPhone and like the iPhone and touch it is going to be easily cracked. Or am i wrong? Also since it has more service area a greater bending pressure can be exerted on it but also there could be thicker glass but that wouldn’t help to much because glass is only strong when under compression not tension.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

11 Answers

ragingloli's avatar

The ipad, because I will follow up with a hammer blow.

njnyjobs's avatar

depending on the height of the fall, both devices will get damaged. The question becomes how extensive will the damage be. . . .

dpworkin's avatar

OK, but what if it was, like, Superman’s iPad, and he gave it powers?

Spinel's avatar

I’ve dropped my laptop several times…nothing fatal. Yet…

The glass screen of the ipad will definitely go first. It doesn’t have protection like a laptop.

FiRE_MaN's avatar

Thats what i said spinel. Especially if its dropped on a corner.

Spinel's avatar

@FiRE_MaN It’s a common sense thing to everyone but the Apple designers.

lilikoi's avatar

You could argue that the iPad is somewhat the equivalent of a laptop screen. The laptop no doubt weighs more and is dimensionally larger and presumably not as stiff (although are we assuming that both screens are made of the same material and thickness, or not?). If the computer was dropped such that the screen took the impact first, wouldn’t the weight of the thing act on the screen and wouldn’t the screen see a larger force than the iPad under the same conditions? Also, I’m not sure what specs we are assuming for each, but a laptop typically has a hard drive containing moving parts which is prone to breaking in impacts. Is this also the case for the iPad?

It is possible, likely even I’d think, that the glass of the iPad is designed to withstand simple falls from hands. I don’t think it would be hard to calculate the force exerted on the screen in a fall from a typical height, and then compare this to material data.

JONESGH's avatar

the iPad. I tripped and dropped my MacBook down some stairs and it was fine.

Spinel's avatar

@JONESGH How did that one happen exactly?

JONESGH's avatar

@Spinel my friend’s cat was sitting at the top of the stairs and I didn’t see him until it was too late, needless to say I fell and so did my computer

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther