Meta Question

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

If a question asked doesn’t carry a disclaimer stating it's for information only, should one view the question as having something personally to do with the OP?

Asked by Hypocrisy_Central (26879points) June 15th, 2014

I have noticed many times when someone asks a question rather than leaving room that the question was being asked out of curiosity, the readers believe the question is about a situation or event that is affecting the OP personally. Should questions be viewed as being about the OP leaving no room that the question could be prompted by something the OP read, seen, or that it is just curiosity if the question doesn’t specifically says so?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

Coloma's avatar

WTH…are you talking about?

Tropical_Willie's avatar

Think “Someone is confused and bewildered” but don’t know whom it might be.

El_Cadejo's avatar

You pose an interesting point. I think it depends greatly on how the question is worded and if there is a trend of those types of questions from a certain user.

So my friend has this problem and….” No, they don’t, this question is about you.

That said one could ask questions they’re just curious about then again, if it’s something you’re so curious about as to ask a question about it, how does it not affect you personally?

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

@El_Cadejo That said one could ask questions they’re just curious about then again, if it’s something you’re so curious about as to ask a question about it, how does it not affect you personally?
It doesn’t affect me because I am detached from the situation the question is about. For instance, say someone asks why or what cause some people to get so furious driving in rush hour traffic. They may be asking because a friend, coworker, uncle, etc. always fly into a rage when driving in stop-and-go traffic. The OP might not have a job that requires them to drive in stop-and-go traffic therefore, having no concept what it is about it that makes some people so pissed, so they ask. Some people assume it is the OP having a problem with rush hour traffic or road rage when it has nothing to do with them, thus it has no effect on them because the person getting pissed are not getting pissed at them, and they are not being caught in traffic; it does not involve them personally.

Mimishu1995's avatar

I agree with @El_Cadejo. It depends.

There is time when a question is asked and then it receives responses like: “The fact that you ask this means…” although I’m not really sure if there is really a background story behind the question. I think sometimes people can misunderstand the nature of the question.

GloPro's avatar

It may not be directly pertaining to a situation in the OP’s life, but every question and response, even the fantastical ones and the ones just for fun, will give some insight as to the personality of the poster.

dappled_leaves's avatar

Hey, some people ask question after question on the same type of topic. After a while, it becomes apparent that that person has some kind of personal issue with the topic. One question can totally be given the benefit of the doubt, but a dozen questions? A dozen dozen questions? Probably not.

Also, sometimes when stories about “a friend” or “an article I read” are embarrassing in nature, or when the OP seems to have too personal a stake in the story, then it sounds like that person is making up the “friend” in order to talk about themselves. This is so common a trope that it occurs in most sitcoms eventually.

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

@dappled_leaves One question can totally be given the benefit of the doubt, but a dozen questions? A dozen dozen questions? Probably not.
If a person post 2 dozen questions about sex in varying connotations, they have an obsession/frustration with sex?

Dutchess_III's avatar

For some reason ETPro’s incessant religion questions come to mind. I never did understand why he kept doing that.

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

^ Same name came up but uneding kinky sex questions.

Dutchess_III's avatar

I missed those. I usually don’t tap into NSFW questions. Glad I missed them!

Strauss's avatar

I often used to come across instances of the “I have a friend who…” when I was working on a crisis intervention phone line in the seventies. It seems that no matter how anonymous the situation, some people still have a need for another layer of anonymity.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther