General Question

phoebusg's avatar

How would you design a distributed decision-making system?

Asked by phoebusg (5225points) December 8th, 2010

I’m toying with an idea of a DMS (as per Q). Allowing all members of a group to have visibility to both a decision and its factors or data. Any decision can be amended given secondary feedback. But often there are situations where a decision needs to be made in that moment. So, hold the initial decision as current until further modifications can improve its efficiency. The individuals involved and affected by it get a say as well—replacing static law by dynamic distributed mediation.

Visibility arises from sharing what the individual sees to the best of current technological advances. Video/sound, documents in real-time (safeguards forgeries). As in, the rest of the network can witness directly (increasing the number of witnesses) and verify recordings of an event experienced by a member of the group in the environment,

This discussion is not about whether or not such systems agree with you, but how to best design them. With differing levels of application. (As in current tech, low cost up to future tech, high cost).

A couple of examples in a similar direction: and the haiti tracking websites for stress calls (urls?).

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

6 Answers

roundsquare's avatar

This sounds like it might be interesting if I knew what it meant.

Can you be a more concrete? Give an example of the type of DMS you are talking about? What kinds of problems do you want to solve? What kind of data? Is this aggregated human decision making or something like an expert machine? Are we talking some sort of learning algorithm? What do you mean by visibility?

phoebusg's avatar

@roundsquare I added some more context. Any kind of data, but you can use an example if that helps you. Decisions could be computer-aided. You definitely have to crunch statistics of say an affected community (as in someone doing something disagreeable affecting a community).

koanhead's avatar

In terms of implementation I suppose I’d start with a Drupal application, mostly since I have a Drupal install already set up. Undoubtedly this would involve coding up one or more custom modules. Sadly PHP is the only language in which I have any measurable competence so while Drupal isn’t the best framework possible for such an endeavor, it’s the best one for me right now were I to implement such a thing.
I haven’t checked out your earthengine link, but I expect I’d crib shamelessly from it.
Basically, I am just barely competent if that to design or implement such a thing, and therefore my answer is essentially useless. Oh well.

BarnacleBill's avatar

Off the top of my head, I could see constructing a system for a closed group in something like Sharepoint WSS. Problems/decisions could be documented in discussion format, allowing for shared imput. Documents could be reviewed and edited by multiple users. Wiki formatted pages could used to share past history and context setting information, but also a history of decisions while keeping them editable. A multipart web page format would allow for embedding links to third party sites containing information relevant to the project. A workflow would allow for the routing of decisions/sign-offs/delegated tasks assigned to group members.

Kayak8's avatar

I am not a computer person, but I am have worked in a variety of real-world situations where such an application would be beneficial. The physical model we have used is that of the Incident Command System and I think it might be practically applied to the question (not to mention that automating ICS functions would have practical benefit). There is a free computer course at called ICS 100 that explains the basics pretty well.

Essentially ICS was developed by the National Fire Service when companies responded from across the country to address western wild fires. Their radios didn’t always talk to each other and they each had their own command structure which made it insane to coordinate efforts and track accomplishments. We have implemented the very same design at our state health department to address outbreaks of concern (food-borne/water-borne illnesses, etc.) with great success. ICS does a great job of making all the tasks visible to all the members of the group and dependent tasks can be identified—it just all happens on paper in the settings I have used it.

The only exception is a card-based system using little pockets to track deployed resources (people, firetrucks, ambulances, search dogs, etc.) and log when they return, track communications, etc.

Vincentt's avatar

At the risk of providing a completely misinformed answer: wasn’t Haskell a language that would be quite suitable here?

Answer this question




to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther