General Question

majorrich's avatar

Snow Tires or all season tires for my old heavy car?

Asked by majorrich (14741points) November 9th, 2015

My old diesel Mercedes is in the shop getting her windshield seals repaired. It is going to be my dedicated winter car because I am more accustomed to rear wheel drive. She needs new tires and I am getting conflicting advice as to tire selection. I had originally thought i would put all season tires on all four corners, but it was mentioned I should put snow tires on the rear. Then someone else tells me to put snow tires all around. It is indeed a heavy (4400 lbs) car, but it is also very underpowered so I am leaning towards snows on the rear. On the other hand, in Ohio, the roads are largely clear most of the time and snows make a lot of noise. Heretofore I’ve had smaller cars and never worried about snow tires, but will need all the help I can to get the good ship peanut-butter rolling. What do you guys think?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

11 Answers

CWOTUS's avatar

I haven’t used snow tires in decades. Literally, “decades”. And for most of my life I’ve lived in climates and around roads similar to yours, I’m sure. (Michigan, Wisconsin and Connecticut, for the most part, though the cars I drive are generally lighter.)

This year I helped to fund a Kickstarter project for ZipGripGo traction aids that you might also find useful as a way to maintain your all-season tires and forgo the hassle of snow tire changes. I haven’t tried them yet, since they were just delivered this summer, but the videos have convinced me of their utility and value.

AlaskaTundrea's avatar

I live in Alaska and have always been told that whatever I use, I need to use the same thing on all four tires. I’m currently running studded tires, tho’ know they aren’t legal everywhere.

jerv's avatar

I’m thinking all four need to match, regardless. To do otherwise will change the handling of the car in very unbalanced ways. And with all the weight that car has, if it starts sliding sideways, you aren’t stopping that no matter what tires you have on it.

LuckyGuy's avatar

I’ll ask you some questions first, answer them and then give my answer.

Are you over 30? Yes.
Have you driven in snow for over decade and know that it is slippery sometimes? Yes
Do you absolutely, positively, need to get somewhere if there is 2 feet of fresh snow? No.
Do you want a pile of 4 tires sitting in your garage all year? No.
Do you prefer to have ~$1000 in your own bank account or the tire store’s? Your own
Result:
Get a nice set of matching All Season radials.

You’ve got a Merc fer crissake! Keep it driving like one – smooth as a baby’s bottom.

BTW -The tire store is not the best source of info. They suffer from “The Barber Always Thinks You Need A Haircut.” syndrome.

elbanditoroso's avatar

What part of Ohio?

North of Akron (meaning Toledo, Cleveland, etc.) – snow tires for sure. Because of the snow belt and proximity to Lake Erie.

South of Akron, probably OK with good radials.

kritiper's avatar

Heard a news report just yesterday: Winter tires on all four.

Tropical_Willie's avatar

Get set of four Bridgestone Blizzaks; they are a winter tire, so they will wear extremely fast in temperature above 70 * F. Also get a spare set of rims for the tires. Just change the rims with tire already on them.

Tropical_Willie's avatar

Most important in new radial snow tires they are not as noisy as the the old “Town & Country” large lug snow tires.

jerv's avatar

@Tropical_Willie Good points. My folks back in NH swear by Blizzaks, and the new tires are indeed quieter.

I generally split the difference and go for a rain tire. They have the drainage to shed snow reasonably well (slightly less likely to clog the treads than regular all-seasons), hard enough to be usable year-round, and are tailor-made for those in-between times where you’re dealing with slush or wet pavement as is commonly the case on well-maintained roads in the winter.

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

Check out your stopping ability and then the turning ability with the regular tires. I can make any heavy vehicle go in snow, it’s stopping and turning that get real hairy at times. Any question about it go for 4 snows. When you really need to stop you’ll wish for four snows. The snow belt is just to my north. I’ve been through this crap alot.

majorrich's avatar

Central Ohio generally doesn’t get the wicked snows like the snow belt except on rare occasions. I was anticipating difficulties I had last winter. I got stuck in a parking lot when the car sunk into the earth as I was at a Scouting event. Probably just new tires would fix that. Kind of embarrassing to get stuck on flat ground though.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther