General Question

Soubresaut's avatar

What's your "ideal society" rubric?

Asked by Soubresaut (13714points) January 30th, 2018

Rubrics—you may know them best as the charts that teachers use to assess papers. Well, now it’s your turn to write one. And you’re writing it for all of society.

Important elements for your rubric to include:
– The dimensions of society you’re going to measure. What do you think is most important for a well-functioning society?
– Criteria that a society needs to meet in each dimension. Describe what success looks like for each dimension. The criteria need to be concrete, specific, and measurable, so that they can be effectively assessed.
– Specific plan for how you’ll measure each criterium—basically, how will you know when society “gets there” or “falls short”?

(Note: you don’t need to make the sliding scale of “most effective” to “least effective” descriptions, nor do you need to figure out how to conjure up a chart format. Just do one description, the “most effective,” for each dimension.)

Finally, if you’re up for it: how would you assess the society you live in, based on your rubric?

(Bonus questions: do you feel that your rubric was successful? Did its results match your own feelings of society, or did the results surprise you? Do you agree with them? Do you feel your rubric illuminated something, or perhaps overlooked something?)

I know this question is a bit broad in scope—that was intentional; I wanted you to be able to narrow down your rubric as you saw fit—and that it may be a bit lengthy to answer, depending on how you answer. Thank you to those who take the time. I really want to better understand the different ways people evaluate society, and I thought this might be a good structure for people to hash out their ideas. I also thought it might be fun to answer, to share a bit of the thought and logic behind some of the opinions you have about the world.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

5 Answers

stanleybmanly's avatar

You’re asking for an enormous amount of tedious work. Suffice it to state that my take on THIS society and the direction in which it is headed is grim indeed. It is a landscape on which galloping wealth disparity forces severe hardships on the society overall. It is a land where all things essential rise in price significantly ahead of overall inflation. Another way of stating this is that not only does the concentration of wealth assure that there is less money to circulate among the nonrich, there is the additional burden around that money buying less. Those with the money see to it that the eternal homily “if you’re broke, it’s your own fault” the determining principle on which our lives must be based. As the overall standard of living tumbles, no one denies it. But instead of addressing the issue as one of systemic failure, we are encouraged to buck the trend as individuals. Thus the proliferation of scams and schemes about “being smart with your money”.

Soubresaut's avatar

It is a lot… On reflection, maybe too much. If that’s stopping anyone from responding, please don’t let it. Do the rubric thing as completely (or incompletely) as you want, or answer like @stanleybmanly did, or however you want.

I guess the question, sans structural requirements, would be this: what does an ideal society look like to you, and how do you know/measure/asses where society is in relation to that ideal?

flutherother's avatar

To answer very briefly, an ideal society is not possible. The best we can hope for is one where the people are free at all times to speak out against what they feel is wrong and to strive to make it better. A free press and a free media are therefore vital. Having a leader you can respect would be a bonus.

I read the Omelas story, and take its moral to heart. A society can be judged on how its lowliest citizens are treated.

Response moderated (Spam)
Response moderated (Spam)

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther