Social Question

LostInParadise's avatar

Does it make sense to celebrate the new year at the start of winter?

Asked by LostInParadise (32023points) December 23rd, 2023

The usual explanation is that people are celebrating the winter solstice, when daylight hours increase. It is still cold. February is the coldest month of the year.

A better choice would be the spring solstice, which is a kind of rebirth of nature. When I went to school, the Jewish new year in fall made sense. Summer vacation was over. Time to get back to work.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

Jeruba's avatar

Some cultures do have their new year in springtime. Ours doesn’t.

jca2's avatar

There is no solstice in Spring. It’s called the Equinox. Spring or Vernal Equinox:

LostInParadise's avatar

Thanks for the correction

seawulf575's avatar

The years are based on the Julian Calendar which is a solar based calendar…365 days in a solar cycle (with one extra every 4 years). Jan 1 is considered the start of the new year, probably because of the Winter Solstice. Yes, it is still winter, but it is the point where they days in the northern hemisphere are the shortest. After the solstice, the days begin getting longer again signaling the beginning of a new cycle.

This was all set up based on being in the Northern Hemisphere which the Greeks, Romans, et al were. In the southern hemisphere the “winter solstice” is actually the longest day of the year. But since all the scientists and the majority of the people on Earth were in the Northern Hemisphere at the time, it was set. For consistency the Julian calendar is used throughout the world.

ragingloli's avatar

I think new year should be celebrated on one’s birthday. It should then also be a holiday (as in, a day off).

Jeruba's avatar

We use the Gregorian calendar. Both Julian and Gregorian are solar-based. The Gregorian corrected the leap year error.

LostInParadise's avatar

The Jewish cakendar is lunar based, but an extra month is inserted every few years to match solar-based calendars. The Islamic calendar is also lunar-based, but they don’t make any corrections, so their holidays, including new year, slide around the solar year.

zenvelo's avatar

New Year’s, in Julian calendars, was celebrated on April1. It was adoption of the Gregorian that moved it to January 1.

The Russian Orthodox New Year is currently celebrated on January 14.

Forever_Free's avatar

Winter beginning is due to astronomical events.
Ask Pope Gregory XIII about Jan 1

Answer this question




to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther