My romantic mixtape needs some jelly magic, any suggestions?

Song to the Siren, by Tim Buckley.

Have a Little Faith in Me. No romantic mix is complete without it.

Stay is also wonderful.

Ain’t too Proud to Beg, What a Wonderful World and Hungry Eyes are all classics as well.

Edit to add: Almost forgot! Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes and Burning for You are also excellent songs. :)

How about some Postal Service action?

Or Jack Johnson?

Thank you all this is a great start! :3

@nikipedia : I tried clicking on the links but it just sends me to the youtube homepage. :(

Sorry, i am on a fucking useless iPad. Try searching for such great heights and banana pancakes.

@nikipedia: Oh man, you made me think of Death Cab for Cutie! There are so many awesome songs from them!

Marching Bands of Manhattan, I’ll Follow you into the Dark, and Transatlanticism are all very romantic and wonderful songs. :)

This one

Why don’t you ask her what she loves or go on a shopping trip together and pick some things out? Then you can share the experience or find music you have both not heard and fall in love with?

Save Room by John Legend

Crazy Love by MIchael Buble

Babylon by David Gray

Talk Tonight by Oasis

One by U2

My Love by Paul McCartney and Wings

You Raise me Up by Josh Groban

As Long as You Love Me by the Backstreet Boys

Oh Yoko by John Lennon

Into the Sun by Sean Lennon

Saltwater by Julian Lennon

Between Us by The Rutles

Something by The Beatles

Wouldn’t it Be Nice by The Beach Boys

Space Age Love Song by Flock of Seagulls

I’ll Tumble For Ya by Culture Club

Against All Odds by Phil Collins

I’m In Love by The Cure

Don’t Dream It’s Over by Crowded House

The Promise by When in Rome

Brighter than Sunshine, by Aqualung, is a really cute song with a tune that’s good for singing along to. It may take a couple of listens to let it grow on you, but I personally like it a lot. :)

“First Day of My Life” by Bright Eyes
“The Guy That Says Goodbye to You” by Griffin House
“Kathleen” by Josh Ritter (even if her name is not Kathleen!)

Thank you all so much, itunes is going to be crying for mercy after i stuff it with all this neat new stuff. :D