Social Question

SmashTheState's avatar

What is the most realistic depiction of the lumpen proletariat on television?

Asked by SmashTheState (12789points) December 31st, 2011

The “lumpen proletariat” – literally translated as “rag workers” – was Marx’s term for the permanent criminal underclass of society: the whores, beggars, boosters, drug dealers, and other petty crooks who supplement welfare or disability payments with penny ante scams and schemes of a morally dubious nature.

I’m currently enjoying my way through the complete set of The Trailer Park Boys, and a great deal of my laughter comes from recognizing a lot of characters and situations from my own life, which has been spent mostly in decades of grinding poverty, living cheek by jowl with a lot of people very like the characters in the program. The people who made Trailer Park Boys clearly have some affection for the underclass while at the same time not whitewashing how squalid and dysfunctional it often is.

I’ve seen a lot of attempts at trying to capture the social milieu of the lumpen proletariat with greater and lesser effect. My Name Is Earl, for example, amusing as it was, had very little to do with the real experiences of the lumpen proletariat. Other programs like Welcome Back Kotter and The White Shadow had similar unrealistic or whitewashed views of the lumpen proles, presumably because they were marketed to the middle class, who are unlikely to enjoy realistic depictions of poverty. Good Times wasn’t bad, but it didn’t really deal much with the lumpen proletariat; it was more about the working poor.

What television program, in your opinion, has or had the most realistic depiction of the lumpen proletariat?

(Note: If you’ve never been poor – and I don’t mean college student poor either – then you’re probably not qualified to judge what’s realistic.)

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

4 Answers

marinelife's avatar

The Dukes of Hazzard.

SmashTheState's avatar

@marinelife So realistic. Just the other day when I ran out of food, I hopped into my $40,000 indestructible racecar and jumped a creek to evade the police, then fired an explosive arrow at the supermarket and sped off with a whole pile of groceries to see my smokin’ hot cousin and banged her all night long. Good call.

zenvelo's avatar

The Wire, Hill Street Blues, both from the perspective of the police though.

Answer this question




to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther