Which video should I choose?

All I know is Blue ray has the best video and audio quality. I hope someone helps you find out the best video based on the information above. Always the best judge is our own eyes!

I would say the first one.
The second one seems to have cut 64px off the sides.

what @ragingloli said :D

@Smitha “All I know is Blue ray has the best video and audio quality”
Not even close. Blu-Ray movies are only 1080p

Have you watched them?

@Brian1946 I have watched them and as I said before, they have the same quality. Except the second file seems to have less resolution than the first, but that’s not very noticeable.

The audio details seem to be identical, so am I correct in concluding that the sound qualities are equal?

How much disk space is each one using?

The first one is smaller than the second. And that’s pretty confusing to me because I don’t think the larger file is of worse quality than the smaller, given that they are both .mkv files. There must be something that makes the file larger.

Are the run times equal?

Yeah.

Because the first one has greater horizontal resolution and uses less disk space, I’d say keep it.

If you’re not sure that you want to delete the second one, perhaps you can transfer it to an external drive.

It could be that the second one uses more disk space because it has source and chapter data, whereas the first one apparently doesn’t.