General Question

rockfan's avatar

"If you need to google search the meaning of a movie after watching it, then it was a failure." Do you agree or disagree with this statement?

Asked by rockfan (14627points) September 19th, 2017 from iPhone

This quote comes from a Fandango review of Darren Aronofsky’s new film “mother!”, and many other people have the same sentiment.

I saw the film last night and thoroughly enjoyed it (even though it’s downright ludicrous at times) but I can understand why the allegorical nature of the film might frustrate casual movie goers who want something instantly gratifying. Personally, I really enjoy a film that requires the viewer to think about the film long after the credits roll. However, professional film critics were given a special note written by Aronofsky before seeing the film, and it explained why he made the movie and what the overall theme was, giving proper context to the film. On the other hand, regular audiences were given an extremely misleading movie trailer that promised a horror film in the vein of Rosemary’s Baby.

Your thoughts?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

Irukandji's avatar

Not necessarily. Sometimes it’s the movie that’s obtuse, but sometimes it’s the viewer. So it’s possible that if you need to Google search the meaning of a movie after watching it, then you are a failure (at interpreting movies).

LDRSHIP's avatar

I disagree, movies can have all kinds of meanings and intentions. What if the movie leaves you wanting to search for answers or think more. This makes it a failure? That’s silly.

My biggest gripe with that line of thinking is when I see a move in theater, what if I missed something or didn’t pick up on every little detail first viewing? Like @Irukandji said sometimes it is the viewer or maybe a combo of movie and viewer.

I really enjoy reading into background or lore of movie if I’ve enjoyed it, Pacific Rim is one that sparked my interest. Some of the comic book movies as well, since I don’t know all the characters in depth like Dr.Strange for example.

ragingloli's avatar

Or maybe the viewer is just dense.
If the director is sending out notes explaining his movie beforehand, it is probably the movie’s fault.

Zaku's avatar

It applies to people who expect movies to supply them with an easily-understood meaning.

Some people think the best films are the ones that leave them thinking long afterwards, and which don’t have one meaning that they could Google.

Of course, there are also just bad movies, and ones who have me wondering long afterwards why anyone would choose to make a film that seems so frustratingly dumb.

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

I’ve seen Mother. I really am unsure how to describe my feelings about it. The word that comes to mind is ‘Weird”, but it’s more than that and I enjoyed it, but yes, there were parts that I too felt were ludicrous and just went over-the-top.

I knew of the film’s allegorical nature but I didn’t research the film. I just wanted to watch it and see what ‘I’ got from the film, and I did pick up on the themes/motifs etc. I did leave the cinema going ‘what the?’ to a degree and I did read up on it more after watching.

It’s a clever film and I do think it’s pretty amazing, but I think if you need to hand people a leaflet explaining the film, perhaps you’ve gone too far. Especially when you’re giving these to film reviewers. Surely they should have an easier time ‘getting’ what he was aiming for? A general audience is more likely to be lost and they don’t have the flyer.

rockfan's avatar

Oddly enough, I’ve actually heard some people say that they understood the allegory right away and that the film was too predictable

Donkeyiscoming's avatar

Perhaps if your acting like the movie is a test and the way you pass is understanding the moral, in this circumstance the answer would be a yes. But my personal opinion is that when people watch movies they should just chill and watch, if they don’t understand the movie ask a friend or as you were talking about looking it up to understand. Usually when I don’t understand a movie I end up not watching it again.

Answer this question




to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther