General Question

RyanS123's avatar

Is a Buescher Tenor Saxophone a Good Instrument to March With?

Asked by RyanS123 (75points) February 20th, 2018 from iPhone

Hey there, Fluther, I was wondering if anyone on here is or has been in the marching world. In a little over a month, I will be starting my 4th out of 5 seasons with my high school marching band and there’s a lot to be excited about. We will be under a new direction, sponsored by an almost completely new board of volunteers, and will also be marching in Disney World this season, so having that with all these new changes excites me and this season is definitely gonna be something really special. With that said, I’ve also been considering starting somewhat all over again by switching my instrument. I have been playing alto saxophone for the past three seasons, but have considered switching the instrument I march with these past couple years. I own a 1950’s Buescher big-bell tenor saxophone that hasn’t came to my use in far too long. I only own it because at the beginning of my freshman year, I played tenor saxophone in my wind ensemble class while looking to be promoted to alto saxophone. I was never been a very good tenor saxophonist, and the teacher made me switch positions with a baritone saxophonist that was struggling on his instrument. It ended up working out perfectly, I found a passion in baritone saxophone that I never would have found otherwise, and he turned out to be very good on tenor saxophone. Alto saxophone was still my main instrument, though, and play baritone saxophone all the time affected my alto saxophone playing in a way I didn’t see coming. Although I really enjoyed playing baritone saxophone (and still do – I play it in jazz band which is only once a week), I was offered a promotion to alto saxophone in February or March of that year and took it up gladly.

Since switching to baritone saxophone that year, I haven’t really played tenor saxophone except for a few songs as a pit member of one of my school’s musicals last year. Even then, I was borrowing a friend’s instrument because my Buescher broke at the first or second rehearsal and was being repaired for most of the rehearsals leading up to the show. But saying that I’m now thinking of playing tenor saxophone in marching band, I pulled the Buescher out for the first time in ten months. When I played it, I definitely could tell that my alto saxophone and baritone saxophone playing was much better as much as I could tell that over a year ago. The thing that really hit me, however, was that the Buescher didn’t seem like the type of instrument I would want to march with. It’s such an old and rusty instrument and you can tell that it was made for classical music. Not to mention how large it seems with the size of the bell. What also stood out to me is that it doesn’t appear to have a spot to put a lyre in, which I’m gonna need for any local parade events we do during the off-season. I know that my district does have tenor saxophones that marching band members are able to borrow, but before I look into that, I was wondering if there was anyone here in the music and/or marching field that was able to tell me if a Buescher is marchable. If so, it isn’t a big deal if it has no spot for a lyre; I can just use my alto saxophone when that situation arises.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

1 Answer

SergeantQueen's avatar

Hello, I am in High school as well, a junior and I march on Alto Saxophone.
I would say that it honestly is based on personal preference. If you want to march on a tenor, you can do that as long as you are able to play and march and do everything required.
People can march on Baritones as you said so it really comes down to personal preference.
You said in your details “The thing that really hit me, however, was that the Buescher didn’t seem like the type of instrument I would want to march with” If you aren’t sure then you probably shouldn’t. You say there is not lyre as well and that might cause an issue unless you can memorize all your music.
As I said I march on alto and I like it because it isn’t super heavy, plus I have a spot for my lyre. I’ve never marched on any other saxophone, but the baritones in my band march on either alto or tenor.
So basically, what it comes down to, is if you feel that the sound fits marching band (you said it has a more classical sound), if you feel that you can march with it comfortably, and your teacher says it’s okay I don’t see why not.
Personally, though, I wouldn’t.
You mentioned it’s rusty and old, and being from the 1950s it’s definitely an antique.As you probably already know, marching bands sometimes play in bad weather such as snow, rain, cold weather, etc and I’d be worried it would ruin it.
If it has a large bell and is meant for classical music (looks like a jazz sax based on what I saw when I googled) it may not fit at all with the rest of the band and could ruin the feel of the piece or just sound out of place.

Other than that though it is just a regular tenor so you probably could get away with playing it, again it’s all up to you and what you feel (along with what the director feels as well)

Could you maybe post a picture on imgur or photobucket or something and send the link here so I could see what yours looks like?

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther