Is it fair to trade my iPod Touch 16gb 2nd gen AND my Blackberry 8900 for an iPhone 3gS 16gb?

Sure, why not? Yes, you’d be trading two devices for one. But (IMO) the iPhone 3gS would be just as good an iPod as the iPod, and a better smartphone than the Blackberry, so…

Fairness can only be determined between the two people trading. What is fair to some may not be fair to others.

@missingbite Good point! I should clarify. I think such a trade is to 2late2be’s advantage in terms of the devices themselves. I think 2late2be gets the advantage of the trade in functionality & convenience terms. But would it be “fair” to the other person? Depends on what they would want to do with the iPod and Blackberry, I guess…

I think you’re getting the short end of the stick here speaking strictly of money.
The Blackberry 8900 is a new phone and iTouches are also in big demand.

@The_Compassionate_Heretic. well, his iPhone is one month old, my touch it isn’t, and my 8900 is maybe 3 months old, both work and look perfect but as I am on pay as you go with AT&T, I can’t have blackberry data on my 8900, which means I can’t sync my email, use AIM or yahoo messenger or anything like that, I think I will be able to do that on the iPhone with the data plan try offer on AT&T, so I’m willing to lose a little bit, to gain that.

I had an iTouch and a BlackBerry Pearl and happily gave up the two to my younger sister for the iPhone 3G and I could not be happier! to go from 2 devices (which we’re great) to one sleek compact device was by far a great move! But this is only my opinion on the topic ^_^ – LB

not a chance.

Dont do it, the 3Gs isnt that big of an update IMO